ABD MULUK BIN ABD MANAN

The idea of creating “the silhouettes of long-lost buildings that once existed on this site emerge” is interesting. I wish there will be a bit more information about the site of the “ruined historical quarter number 2 in Yaroslavl” so I will be able to appreciate more of his design intention. The…

ABD MULUK BIN ABD MANAN

Base on the limited writing on the Project Idea, I don’t really see a clear design intention, besides just providing solution to existing issues. Without clear design intention, it is hard to rationalize the design solution she come up with in her proposal. No technical explanations also on how the…

ABD MULUK BIN ABD MANAN

The project had a strong concept/idea – entering the mountain (from shadows to light); bringing elements of the past at the beginning of its inception. The idea to ‘frame the view’ of the dam is commendable. However, I feel that the designer fails to consider the beauty of the existing site with…

Sacchin Baddhe

The intention & concept is really interesting & humanitarian. A really good take architecturally. The only solution I would suggest would be to have a mix of community & age group engagement with different activities. Same age group would ultimately become stagnant in its activities. Add few more…

Biniyam Debesa

To give more comments the information provided are limited, and the technical details are shallow can’t comment much, it seems a little bit generic design - for upcoming season I will recommend that provide more details - description must be clear and precise I can’t say much more than that!