Carolina de Mesquita, Emilly Rosy, Emanuelly Rodrigues, Jonas Rafael, Letícia Batista
student
Universidad Católica de Pernambuco
Brazil
Urban Design and Landscape
Beirut reveals itself as the main Lebanese city, marked by charms and contrasts resulting from a long history of occupation and a significant economic activity… more
Adli Nadia
advisor
https://www.undip.ac.id/
Indonesia
Comercial Architecture and mixed use building design more
Hi Carolina
its been an Honor to review your project..... :)
this is a beautiful project and make me do some initial research about the site.
this is my comment:
1. The Silos Memorial development should be parallel with the bussiness district development. The bussiness district should be initiated on the first place because it can be an attractor to both Marina and residential area. It can also escalate the land price and the value of the area and give a significant impact on taxes revenue to fund the whole development.
2. This whole development should need a stronger Datum to bind the whole area to create wholeness. On this project, i can only find the green belt as a Datum on the Passenger area, Residential and Truck Parking.
3. The Residential area was design using a cartesian grid that is not like the spirit of Beirut's ancient grid which is so dynamic and sacred.
4. Somehow the Silo memorial was placed quite far from the bussiness district and residential area. it is understood that an active Silo could be dangerous but a memorial places should be near with humanity and urban attraction.
well that's it Carolina... i know that im not personally bonded with Beirut, and i could only understand a bit of historical aspect using a wikipedia and some paper about urbanism in Beirut. so if one of the comment i made was wrong. i hope you can write a feedback to me also....
thnks alot... regards