Gabriel Szymański
student
ARCHIP, Architectural Institute in Prague
Poland
Architecture
From the beginning, our task was to create living space that blended into the natural landscape. In our studio this semester we were working only on physic… more
Hossan Murad
advisor
Ahsanullah University of Science and Technology
Bangladesh
Vernacular architecture. Sustainability. Heritage and heritage conservation.Contemporary… more
Thank you for selecting me as an international juror for your project. I am providing my feedback in accordance with the following sections to aid your understanding. I hope you find this helpful. Should you require further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me again.
1. Strengths of the Project:
Your initiative to seamlessly integrate architecture with nature has been executed successfully, primarily due to the organic shape of the form and the inclusion of tall trees throughout the roof. This approach effectively merges the project with its natural surroundings. Additionally, natural ventilation and lighting have been appropriately addressed.
2. Weaknesses of the Project:
There is a need for a clearer concept regarding the program of this project, particularly in terms of the separation of public and private spaces. It is unclear how public access to the roof, designated as a public space, will be managed, given that the two floors below are intended for residential use. More detailed floor plans and sectional drawings are required to clarify this. Furthermore, the structural system for these floors is not well-defined. While supporting a tent roof may not pose a significant challenge, the floors could create two issues: disrupting the natural setting of the site and aesthetically clashing with the organic forms and trees.
3. Opportunities of the Project:
In this contemporary period, there is a strong focus on environmental sustainability and minimalist architectural design, which aim to minimize harm to nature while maximizing functionality. By continuing this style, you have the potential to develop a distinctive architectural approach. Many architects today are incorporating vernacular or organic materials such as bamboo, mud, or various types of tensile fabrics into their projects, as these materials are more sustainable in terms of cost, availability, and construction techniques.
4. Threats to the Project:
Natural disasters such as landslides, forest fires, cyclones, heavy rainfall, and strong winds pose significant threats. The presence of trees within the built environment could result in uncontrollable loss of life and property during such events. It is essential to develop technical strategies to mitigate these risks.
Thank you.