Mingda Yang, Yaojie Zhong
student
Politecnico di Milano, Polytechnic University of Milan, School of Design
Italy
Urban Design and Landscape
The site is located in a scenic valley surrounded by mountains and dense forests. This area is famous for its rich natural landscape and attracts hiking… more
AbdelRahman Badawy
advisor
Cairo University, Faculty of Engineering Architecture Department.
Egypt
Architectural Design, AI in Architecture more
Your project showcases a strong and conceptually grounded morphology. The philosophical foundation is both compelling and profound, successfully translating into various aspects of the design, including the layout, facades, and interiors. The structural design is logical and feasible, and the spatial sensations are harmonious, comfortable, and well-aligned with the overarching concept.
However, there are a few areas that could benefit from further refinement:
• Aesthetics of Facades: While the overall aesthetics are commendable, the proportions of openings and the composition of materials on the facades, particularly on the residential building, could be further developed to enhance visual appeal and coherence.
• Privacy of Residential Units: There is a lack of clear boundaries between the residential units and the adjacent public areas, which compromises privacy.
• Integration of Buildings and Landscape: The relationship between the buildings and their surrounding landscape needs better integration. For example, the connection between the residential building and its greenery (Ecological Farm).
• Architectural Representation: While the project is well-presented and rendered, some elements in the representation are unclear or misleading, such as the directions and leveling of the stairs.