Bledar Hazrolli, Eron Berisha, Jonë Krasniqi, Anesë Latifi
student
University of Prishtina
Kosovo
Architecture
The concept of the hotel's form is based on Zen philosophy, which embraces the beauty of simplicity, imperfection, and interaction with nature. The generation… more
Andriy Golub
advisor
Kyiv National University of Construction and Architecture
Ukrainian
Golub Architects Company and me, as the chief architect, have several focuses: firstly, it is a… more
The project presentation of "Arya Hotel" consists of 18 sheets, which logically and very coherently present the information. Sheet 2 contains the situational diagram and urban planning analysis of the area, which immediately clarifies the location of the project and the initial urban planning conditions and constraints. Sheet 3 outlines the concept, based on the aesthetics of simplicity.
Sheets 4 to 13 detail the solutions for the master plan and floor plans. According to these solutions, it is clear that the building is designed with a frame construction system, and the frame itself is designed using reinforced concrete. Sheets 14 and 15 present cross-sections, from which the height of each floor can be assessed, with the first floor designed at 4.8 meters, and all other floors (basement, second, third, and fourth) at 2.8 meters.
Overall, the work is completed at a high level. The visualizations of the exterior and interior are done in a very stylish manner.
At the same time, there are a few technical comments. First, there are questions regarding the placement of axes; it is generally accepted to place lettered axes horizontally and numbered axes vertically, but here they seem to be switched. Secondly, there are two axes marked with the number 2 on the plans, which is incorrect. It would be better to use a different designation, such as 2/A in certain situations. Third, the thickness of the ceiling raises concerns—only 200 mm. We know that hotel rooms must include a forced ventilation system with heat recovery, and ventilation ducts are typically placed under the ceiling of each floor, which increases the ceiling thickness. Therefore, it is quite doubtful that a 200 mm ceiling height could be maintained at the stage of working documentation.
Overall, the above comments do not affect the overall impression of the work, which has been completed at a high professional level. I wish the authors of this work—Bledar Hazrolli, Eron Berisha, Jonë Krasniqi, and Anesë Latifi—further creative success and the completion of new strong projects.