María Elizabeth Maldonado

advisor

Universidad de Cuenca

Ecuador

My architectural focus is centered on sustainable design, integrating architectural and urban… more

Dear Wenny Wenny,

It has been a pleasure to review your project on the revitalization of Pancoran Glodok. Your approach to addressing the loss of sense of place due to modernization and commercialization is well-grounded in urban theory and cultural preservation strategies. The project successfully integrates key city image elements, incorporating nodes, edges, landmarks, and pathways in a way that reinforces the historical and cultural identity of the area.

Strengths:
_ Your project effectively addresses the challenges of urban transformation, particularly the impact of commercialization on traditional architecture and social dynamics.
- The use of Qi and Wu Ji as conceptual frameworks demonstrates cultural sensitivity in design, ensuring that revitalization aligns with the values of the site.
- Integration of public spaces, such as Chinatown Gate, the Art Gallery, and the Amphitheater, fosters community engagement and enhances urban vibrancy.
- The pedestrian-oriented design, featuring five footways and continuous pathways, improves walkability and connectivity while supporting multifunctional public spaces.
- The architectural identity, reflected in the restoration of traditional shophouse façades and the selection of elements such as roofs, windows, and doors, strengthens the district’s heritage preservation efforts.

Areas for Improvement:

. Visual hierarchy and representation: While your diagrams and maps effectively illustrate the design interventions, enhancing the differentiation of layers in sections and perspectives could improve clarity and readability.
- Strengthening sustainability strategies: The project addresses long-term preservation, but incorporating green infrastructure—such as passive cooling strategies, rainwater collection, and permeable surfaces—could further strengthen its resilience and environmental impact.
- Community participation process: While the project highlights existing cultural activities such as walking tours, an expanded participatory approach—including direct input from local vendors and residents—could further refine the interventions and ensure long-term success.

Your project presents a well-thought-out and compelling approach to revitalizing Pancoran Glodok while maintaining its historical integrity. Further refinements in visual representation, sustainability strategies, and participatory planning could enhance its contribution to urban revitalization efforts. Congratulations on your thoughtful and inspiring work!

Best regards,
María Elizabeth Maldonado
INSPIRELI AWARDS Jury